Monthly Archives: February 2019

H2H 6: Marshall Faulk vs. LaDainian Tomlinson – Who was Better?

Running backs come in all shapes and sizes – big bruisers, shifty speedsters, goal-line specialists, third-down pass-catching backs, etc.  In an era of increasing specialization and running backs by committee, the most coveted backs are still the ones that can play all three downs and represent both a rushing and receiving threat.  Any list of the most dangerous all-purpose backs in NFL history who were equally good at running between the tackles and catching a screen pass in the flat would include Marshall Faulk and LaDainian Tomlinson.  As football fans and fantasy players of the last 20 years will remember, in their prime, Faulk and Tomlinson were elite offensive weapons who racked up yards, catches, and perhaps most importantly, touchdowns at an extraordinary rate, on their way to Hall of Fame careers.  With both players having hung up their cleats and been immortalized in Canton, the question is:

Who was better – Marshall Faulk or LaDainian Tomlinson?

Continue reading

H2H 5: Jimmy Connors vs. John McEnroe – Who was Better?

As one of the true individual head-to-head sports, tennis has always had its share of great rivalries between often very contrasting players, whether it be Roger Federer vs. Rafael Nadal currently, Pete Sampras vs. Andre Agassi in the 1990s, or Chris Evert vs. Martina Navratilova in the 1970s and 1980s, etc.  One of tennis history’s greatest rivalries featured two American men, Jimmy Connors and John McEnroe, who were known as much for their volatile and bombastic personalities as they were for their skills with a tennis racquet. Throughout much of the 1970s and 1980s, Connors and McEnroe would sit at or near the pinnacle of men’s tennis, racking up wins, titles, and Grand Slams, as well as fines. More than 30 years after either man was last ranked #1 in the world, the debate still goes on today:

Who was better – Jimmy Connors or John McEnroe?

Continue reading

H2H 4: Mickey Mantle vs. Willie Mays – Who was Better?

1957 was a year that rocked the baseball world in New York and marked the end of a golden age of America’s pastime in Gotham.  Of the three storied teams that had called New York home for more than a half century (the Yankees in the Bronx, the Dodgers in Brooklyn, and the Giants in Manhattan), both the Dodgers and Giants packed their bags and moved west to the greener pastures of California (to Los Angeles and San Francisco, respectively).  Up until that time, baseball fans had been treated to a trio of Hall of Fame sluggers patrolling center field in New York – Mickey Mantle for the Yankees, Duke Snider for the Dodgers, and Willie Mays for the Giants. While Snider was an outstanding player in his own right (an 8x All-Star with 407 career home runs who was inducted to the Hall of Fame in 1980), Mantle and Mays were considered not only among the preeminent players of their time, but are arguably two of the greatest center fielders in baseball history.  In stacking up their career achievements alongside each other, the question arises:

Who was better – Mickey Mantle or Willie Mays?

Continue reading

H2H 3: Martin Brodeur vs. Patrick Roy – Who was Better?

When it comes to the most important positions in sports, the shortlist contains the usual suspects: quarterback, goalie, starting pitcher, basketball superstar (not technically a position, but one player can thoroughly carry a team, e.g. LeBron James when he was on the Cleveland Cavaliers).  Perhaps because of hockey’s status as the fourth of the “Big 4” American sports, great goalies may not get the same amount of attention as a Tom Brady, Clayton Kershaw, or the aforementioned James, but the men in masks and pads can single-handedly steal a game, a series, or even an entire playoffs for their teams with their stellar play in net.  Over the last quarter-century or so, two French-Canadians, Martin Brodeur and Patrick Roy, have stood tall in net as titans of goaltending in the NHL, Hall of Famers with the most and second-most wins in history, respectively. With Brodeur recently being inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame in 2018, that brings up the question:

Who was better – Martin Brodeur or Patrick Roy?

Continue reading