Monthly Archives: July 2019

H2H 28: Pete Rose vs. Ichiro Suzuki – Who was Better?

On June 15, 2016, Ichiro Suzuki tallied two hits against the San Diego Padres to reach 2,979 for his MLB career; coupled with his 1,278 hits in Japan, that gave him 4,257 total professional hits, thus surpassing Pete Rose’s total of 4,256 professional hits (all accumulated in MLB).  Though most baseball fans and pundits still consider Rose the all-time hits king due to the differences between American and Japanese professional baseball, this milestone nevertheless highlighted the incredible hitting prowess and consistency and longevity of two of baseball’s legendary hitters.  Despite the differences in era, ethnicity, and personality, the two men are bonded by their shared affinity for gathering hits and tenacious, unrelenting style of play, leading to the natural comparisons and thus, the question:

Who was better – Pete Rose or Ichiro Suzuki?

Continue reading

H2H 27: Troy Polamalu vs. Ed Reed – Who was Better?

Note: Updated for Troy Polamalu’s 2020 Hall of Fame selection.

Since the original Cleveland Browns moved to Baltimore and became the Ravens in 1996, the Pittsburgh Steelers vs. the Baltimore Ravens in the AFC North has become one of the fiercest divisional rivalries in the NFL.  While individual players have come and gone, the themes of this intense rivalry have remained essentially the same since inception – power running games and hard-hitting defenses. Perhaps no two players better embodied this rivalry than All-Pro safeties Troy Polamalu of the Steelers and Ed Reed of the Ravens.  Both were linchpins of their respective defenses for a decade and achieved the heights of personal and team success (Pro Bowl, All-Pro, Defensive Player of the Year, Super Bowl) – given how closely their careers overlapped and how often they played against each other, this leads to inevitable comparisons and the overarching question:

Who was better – Troy Polamalu or Ed Reed?

Continue reading

H2H 26: Clyde Drexler vs. George Gervin – Who was Better?

Any discussion of the best shooting guards in NBA history usually starts with Michael Jordan and Kobe Bryant at the top of the list, though the historical roster of great two-guards is deep and versatile, ranging from the recently retired Dwyane Wade to offensive dynamos such as James Harden to silky smooth shooters like Ray Allen and Reggie Miller.  Among this group, two of the more underrated and perhaps under-appreciated shooting guards/wings are Clyde “The Glide” Drexler and George “The Iceman” Gervin, franchise mainstays who quietly went about doing their thing on a nightly basis and were always among the best players in the league, but never quite “The Man”. Nevertheless, both players are rightfully immortalized in Springfield and deserve mention in any conversations about top shooting guards throughout the Association’s history – however, between the two:

Who was better – Clyde Drexler or George Gervin?

Continue reading

H2H 25: Jari Kurri vs. Teemu Selanne – Who was Better?

On March 12, 2012, Teemu Selanne scored his 659th career goal and 1,399th career point against the Colorado Avalanche, thus surpassing Jari Kurri as the all-time leading scorer in NHL history among Finnish-born players.  While Finland has often been overshadowed by its neighbor Sweden in hockey, it has nevertheless produced its fair share of NHL players, chief among them Kurri and Selanne, two of the top players of their respective generations and both Hall of Fame members.  Between these two “Finnish Flashes”, who remain #1 and #2 in scoring among their countrymen and are also close friends in real life, their great careers beg the question:

Who was better – Jari Kurri or Teemu Selanne?

Continue reading