Category Archives: Baseball

H2H 67: Hank Aaron vs. Stan Musial – Who was Better?

After Pete Rose (4,256) and Ty Cobb (4,191), no players in MLB history have more career hits than Hank Aaron at #3 (3,771) and Stan Musial at #4 (3,630).  With careers spanning well over 20 seasons apiece, Aaron and Musial accomplished it all during their playing days – 20+ All-Star selections each, MVP awards, batting titles, World Series championships, and a plethora of career hitting records.  Interestingly, the younger Aaron viewed Musial as one of his baseball idols and the two later became lifelong friends; given their similar career statistics and accomplishments (with the exception of Aaron’s clear superiority in hitting home runs), it is a natural comparison to ask:

Who was better – Hank Aaron or Stan Musial?

Continue reading

Countdown 35: Top 10 Shortstops in MLB History

Who are the top shortstops in MLB history?  Here is our top 10 countdown:

Continue reading

H2H 63: Derek Jeter vs. Cal Ripken Jr. – Who was Better?

Along with catcher, shortstop is arguably one of the most important positions in baseball, so much so that teams are willing to sacrifice offense for superior defense.  Thus, when a team comes across a unicorn shortstop that excels with both the bat and the glove, that player can serve as a franchise centerpiece; in fact, looking through the history of baseball, many of the game’s greatest shortstops have spent their entire careers with one franchise, e.g. Ernie Banks of the Chicago Cubs, Robin Yount of the Milwaukee Brewers, Barry Larkin of the Cincinnati Reds, Alan Trammell of the Detroit Tigers, etc.  At the top of this list are Derek Jeter and Cal Ripken Jr. – both spent their entire careers spanning 20+ years with one team, compiled over 3,000 career hits, won World Series titles, and were inducted into the Hall of Fame, leading to the inevitable question:

Who was better – Derek Jeter or Cal Ripken Jr.?

Continue reading

Countdown 29: Top 10 Second Basemen in MLB History

Who are the top second basemen in MLB history?  Here is our top 10 countdown:

Continue reading

H2H 59: Jeff Kent vs. Ryne Sandberg – Who was Better?

The history of MLB second basemen is an interesting one – while some of the greatest players of the early 20th century manned second base (e.g. Rogers Hornsby, Eddie Collins, Nap Lajoie, etc.), it has not traditionally been viewed as a position for sluggers nor does it have the defensive value of catcher, shortstop, or center field.  Nevertheless, it has seen its share of MVP and Hall of Fame-caliber players over the years; in particular, two of the top slugging second basemen in recent memory have been Jeff Kent and Ryne Sandberg. Sandberg retired with the most career home runs by a second baseman, while Kent currently holds that distinction, thus prompting the question:

Who was better – Jeff Kent or Ryne Sandberg?

Continue reading

Countdown 26: Top 10 New York Yankees of All Time

Who are the top New York Yankees of all time?  Here is our top 10 countdown:

Continue reading

H2H 56: Don Mattingly vs. Kirby Puckett – Who was Better?

With big-money free agency dominating professional sports these days, it is rare for athletes to spend their entire careers with one team.  As such, we often look back with nostalgia on ballplayers who did indeed only play for one team during their professional careers; during the 1980s and 1990s, two MLB superstars who epitomized this bygone era were Don Mattingly of the New York Yankees and Kirby Puckett of the Minnesota Twins, who for a decade, were each the heart and soul of their respective teams.  As their careers essentially overlapped and both players retired in the same year with highly comparable numbers, it is only natural to ask:

Who was better – Don Mattingly or Kirby Puckett?

Continue reading

Countdown 23: Top 10 First Basemen in MLB History

Who are the top first basemen in MLB history?  Here is our top 10 countdown:

Continue reading

H2H 52: Rod Carew vs. Tony Gwynn – Who was Better?

At the 2016 All-Star Game, MLB renamed the AL and NL batting title trophies after Rod Carew and Tony Gwynn, respectively, an apt tribute given each player’s hitting prowess – after all, only six players in baseball history have won seven or more batting titles: Ty Cobb (12x), Honus Wagner (8x), Gwynn (8x), Carew (7x), Stan Musial (7x), and Rogers Hornsby (7x).  As baseball has evolved more and more into a game of the “three true outcomes” (home run, walk, or strikeout), Carew and Gwynn were unique in that neither was a power hitter, but instead, consistent .300+ contact hitters who each amassed 3,000+ career hits over nearly two decades. Given their similar games and the fact that they will be forever immortalized together as batting champion namesakes, it is only natural to ask:

Who was better – Rod Carew or Tony Gwynn?

Continue reading

H2H 50: Sandy Koufax vs. Pedro Martinez – Who was Better?

When it comes to the most dominant pitchers in MLB history, two names that often come to mind are Sandy Koufax and Pedro Martinez.  With a lethal combination of movement and overpowering stuff, each pitcher was nearly unhittable in his prime, racking up the strikeouts, wins, and Cy Youngs – in fact, their respective five-year peaks are some of the most dominant pitching performances the game of baseball has ever seen.  Despite their careers being separated by 40 years, the striking similarities between these legendary Hall of Fame hurlers leads us to ask:

Who was better – Sandy Koufax or Pedro Martinez?

Continue reading