Tag Archives: best power forwards in NBA history

H2H 69: Charles Barkley vs. Elgin Baylor – Who was Better?

Basketball has historically been a game dominated by taller players; in particular, when it comes to the paint area near the hoop, towering forwards and centers measuring close to seven feet tall battle each other to score and rebound.  However, despite these archetypes, every so often an undersized player comes around and outplays the competition in spite of his height – during the NBA’s history, two undersized players fitting this description were 6’6” Charles Barkley and 6’5” Elgin Baylor.  Though each player often gave up a few inches to the competition, both were 20-and-10 machines who played well above their height en route to Hall of Fame careers, thus prompting the question:

Who was better – Charles Barkley or Elgin Baylor?

Continue reading

H2H 30: Kevin Garnett vs. Dirk Nowitzki – Who was Better?

Note: Updated for Kevin Garnett’s 2020 Hall of Fame selection.

Throughout most of the NBA’s history, seven-foot centers and forwards have traditionally played close to the basket and focused on scoring and rebounding in the paint.  In the mid to late-1990s, however, the first wave of “unicorn” players began to emerge in the shape of versatile seven-footers who could dribble, pass, and shoot with the skills of a guard (yes, that included making three-pointers).  Two of these early unicorns were high schooler Kevin Garnett and German-born Dirk Nowitzki, who went from being raw, but talented teenagers to franchise faces and league MVPs. With both players having retired in recent years, the landscape of the NBA has changed dramatically since when they first entered the league – now, positionless seven-footers such as Kevin Durant, Giannis Antetokounmpo, and Kristaps Porzingis are becoming increasingly valuable for their unique skill sets.  As we look back upon a couple of the prototypes of the modern basketball player, a natural question arises:

Who was better – Kevin Garnett or Dirk Nowitzki?

Continue reading

H2H 21: Tim Duncan vs. Karl Malone – Who was Better?

Note: Updated for Tim Duncan’s 2020 Hall of Fame selection.

Over time, the role of the NBA power forward has evolved from a big, bruising player who, together with the center, does most of his work close to the rim (think Bob Pettit) into a more agile, versatile player who can play all over the court (e.g. Kevin Love).  However, even as the profile of the power forward has changed over time, any discussion of the greatest power forwards in league history continues to revolve among a few names, including Tim Duncan of the San Antonio Spurs and Karl Malone of the Utah Jazz. Both were multiple-time MVP winners and consistent First Team All-NBA performers – in comparing their careers side-by-side, the question is:

Who was better – Tim Duncan or Karl Malone?

Continue reading