Tag Archives: longest-serving NHL captains

H2H 141: Shane Doan vs. Ryan Smyth – Who was Better?

Every sports team’s fan base has its share of franchise favorites – though these may not necessarily be the best players in the team’s history (they can be), they have usually been around with the team through thick and thin and are both leaders and class acts.  For the Arizona Coyotes and the Edmonton Oilers in the NHL, perhaps the most popular players in (recent) franchise history are Shane Doan and Ryan Smyth, respectively – outstanding hockey players in their own right, they each led their respective teams through rather bleak periods with class and dignity, thus forever earning a place in the hearts of the fans; given their relatively parallel careers, it is only natural to compare the pair and ask:

Who was better – Shane Doan or Ryan Smyth?

Continue reading

H2H 20: Joe Sakic vs. Steve Yzerman – Who was Better?

One of the greatest honors for an NHL player is to wear the captain’s “C” at some point during his career, as it signifies both excellence in play and in leadership ability.  With the advent of free agency and players moving around from team to team, it has become increasingly rare for a team to have a captain for an extended period of time, e.g. a decade of more.  In recent history, Joe Sakic and Steve Yzerman come to mind as great captains who played their entire 20+ year Hall of Fame careers with one franchise and led their respective teams to the Stanley Cup.  There are many career similarities between the two (both from Canada, both played center, both spent their entire career with one team, both were 1,500+ point scorers and strong two-way players, both were relatively quiet and chose to lead by example, etc.), thus it is only natural to compare them and ask:

Who was better – Joe Sakic or Steve Yzerman?

Continue reading