Tag Archives: best undrafted players in NFL history

H2H 148: Antonio Gates vs. Jason Witten – Who was Better?

With the evolution of the passing game in football, the tight end position has likewise undergone a revolution from primarily an extra blocker to a versatile pass-catching weapon.  In particular, the 21st century NFL has not only seen all-world tight ends like Tony Gonzalez and Rob Gronkowski (arguably two of the best tight ends ever), but also dominant forces like Antonio Gates and Jason Witten – the former is the most prolific scorer in league history at the position, while the latter is the all-time iron man among tight ends and also once held the single-season tight ends receptions record.  Both longtime legends announced their retirement in recent years and are most assuredly Hall of Famers, thus bringing up the debate:

Who was better – Antonio Gates or Jason Witten?

Continue reading

H2H 140: James Harrison vs. Joey Porter – Who was Better?

Beginning with the days of the “Steel Curtain” in the 1970s, the Pittsburgh Steelers have always been characterized by a ferocious defense; in particular, from the likes of Greg Lloyd and Kevin Greene to Jason Gildon to T.J. Watt today, a hallmark of their defensive scheme has consistently been elite pass-rushing outside linebackers.  Notably, in the 2000s, the Steelers defense was anchored by successive brash pass-rushers, first with Joey Porter and then followed by James Harrison.  Both among the top five career sack leaders in team history, each was an intimidating (and perhaps at times, dirty) player who will go down in team lore as a legend, but the question is:

Who was better – James Harrison or Joey Porter?

Continue reading