This site contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.
Note: Updated in 2023.
Throughout football history, the role of the tight end has evolved from a lumbering extra blocker on the offensive line to a dynamic, multi-faceted weapon with the ability to create mismatches on defense and dominate as a pass-catcher in the red zone while also contributing to the running game. From the early days of tight ends like Mike Ditka and John Mackey to Ozzie Newsome and Shannon Sharpe, football fans have been witnesses to a tight end revolution over the past couple of decades, with two notable names in Tony Gonzalez and Rob Gronkowski at the vanguard of the “new age” tight end. With Gronkowski’s recent retirement, a natural debate arises between Gonzalez’s long-term brilliance and Gronkowski’s epic zenith:
Who was better – Tony Gonzalez or Rob Gronkowski?
The Beginning
Both Gonzalez and Gronkowski parlayed high school athletic prowess into All-American college football careers, which in turn led to early round NFL selections.
Growing up in California, Gonzalez was a high school star in both football (First Team All-American at tight end and linebacker) and basketball (Orange County and Sunset League MVP), and as a senior, shared Orange County High School Athlete of the Year honors with Tiger Woods (heard of him?). After staying in-state at UC Berkeley, he continued to be a two-sport star for the Golden Bears, earning All-Pac-10 and All-American honors in football and making the Sweet Sixteen in March Madness. Following his junior year, Gonzalez entered the 1997 NFL Draft and was selected 13th overall in the first round by the Kansas City Chiefs (who had traded up from 18th to pick him); as a rookie, he made the All-Rookie team on the back of 33 receptions for 368 yards and 2 touchdowns.
As for Gronkowski, he grew up in a family of athletes – his great-grandfather was a record-breaking cyclist at the 1924 Summer Olympics in Paris, his father played college football at Syracuse, and all four of his brothers played college and professional sports, including three fellow NFL players. As a highly recruited All-American prep star in both New York and later Pennsylvania, he went all the way across the country to the University of Arizona for college, where as a freshman, he garnered Freshman All-American and Pac-10 honors. Then, as a sophomore, Gronkowski soared to even greater heights, making both the AP All-American Third Team and All-Pac-10 First Team. While even more was expected of him as a junior, he missed the entire season with an injury, but nevertheless declared early for the 2010 NFL Draft and was drafted 42nd overall in the second round by the New England Patriots. Gronkowski would make a splash as a rookie, accumulating 42 catches for 546 yards and 10 touchdowns, thus becoming the first rookie tight end since the NFL-AFL merger to score double-digit touchdowns.
Career Comparison
Over his long career with the Chiefs and Falcons, Gonzalez would be a pillar of consistency as he established himself as one of the greatest tight ends ever and one of the best players of his generation; while Gronkowski was plagued by injuries and had a much shorter career, he was as good as Gonzalez, if not better, at his healthy peak.
After improving further in his second season, Gonzalez broke out with the first of 10 straight Pro Bowl nods (and 14 overall), as well as three straight All-Pro selections (and six overall), with 76 receptions for 849 yards and a career-best 11 touchdowns in 1999. This was followed by 93 catches for 1,203 yards and 9 touchdowns in 2000, and another Pro Bowl/All-Pro season in 2001 with 73 catches for 917 yards and 6 touchdowns. From this point forward, Gonzalez would put up at least 60 catches for 600+ yards in every single season of his career.
In 2004, Gonzalez had a career-best year with a career-high 102 catches (a then-NFL tight end record that has since been eclipsed by Jason Witten, Travis Kelce, and Zach Ertz) for a career-best 1,258 yards and 7 touchdowns, including a career-best 14 catches for 144 yards in Week 17. Meanwhile, in 2006, in the midst of a 73 catch-900 yard-5 touchdown season, he became the Chiefs’ all-time leader in receiving yards, receiving touchdowns, and yards from scrimmage. This was followed by another two consecutive seasons of 1,000+ receiving yards in 2007 (99 catches for 1,172 yards and 5 touchdowns) and 2008 (96 receptions for 1,058 yards and 10 touchdowns; also his last All-Pro season in Kansas City); during the 2007 season, Gonzalez would surpass Shannon Sharpe for both the most career receptions and receiving touchdowns by a tight end, and in 2008, he would pass Sharpe for most career receiving yards by a tight end.
Citing a desire to win, Gonzalez was traded in 2009 to the Atlanta Falcons for a second-round pick in the 2010 NFL Draft; despite putting up another solid season with 83 catches for 867 yards and 6 touchdowns in his inaugural season in Atlanta, he would miss the Pro Bowl for the first time in a decade. Nevertheless, he would make the Pro Bowl in each of his remaining four seasons with the Falcons, with his best year coming in 2012 (93 catches for 930 yards and 8 touchdowns). After the 2013 season, in which he was still an elite tight end (83 receptions for 859 yards and 8 touchdowns), Gonzalez hung up his cleats at age 37.
Gronkowski’s superb rookie season was a prelude of things to come. In his second season in 2011, he had a monster season with 90 receptions for 1,327 yards and 17 touchdowns, thus earning both Pro Bowl and First Team All-Pro honors. The 1,327 receiving yards were a then-tight end record, surpassing the 1,310 yards set by fellow tight end Jimmy Graham on the same day; moreover, the 17 receiving touchdowns continue to be a single-season record for tight ends, easily surpassing the previous record of 13 held by both Antonio Gates and Vernon Davis.
Though he would break his left forearm in 2012 and be limited to 11 games, Gronkowski still had another Pro Bowl season with 55 catches for 790 yards and 11 touchdowns, becoming only the third tight end (behind Gonzalez and Gates) to put up three double-digit touchdown seasons and the first one to do so consecutively. After forearm injuries and a torn ACL/MCL limited him to only seven games and ended his season early in 2013, he bounced back with two straight Pro Bowl and All-Pro seasons in 2014 and 2015:
- 2014: 82 receptions for 1,124 yards and 12 touchdowns; earned Comeback Player of the Year honors and became the first tight end with four double-digit touchdown seasons
- 2015: 72 receptions for 1,176 yards and 11 touchdowns
In 2016, injuries (back injuries this time) limited Gronkowski to only eight games, though he did become the Patriots’ all-time touchdown leader that year. He once again bounced back in 2017 with 69 catches for 1,084 yards and 8 touchdowns, earning his final Pro Bowl and All-Pro selections and becoming the third tight end in NFL history with four 1,000-yard receiving seasons (behind Gonzalez and Jason Witten). Following another strong season in 2018 (47 receptions for 682 yards and 3 touchdowns) and another Super Bowl victory (more on that later), Gronkowski made the somewhat surprising decision to retire early at the relatively young age of 29 (though he had been contemplating it for a couple of seasons).
After just one season of retirement, however, Gronkowski unretired in 2020 to reunite with Tom Brady on the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. In two seasons in Florida, he was good, but not quite his earlier dominant self, topping out at 55 catches for 802 yards and 6 touchdowns in 2021 before hanging up his cleats (again) at the end of the season.
Given he played nearly twice as many career games, Gonzalez has the clear edge over Gronkowski in every major career receiving category, from receptions to yards to touchdowns. In fact, as of the end of the 2018 season, Gonzalez was not only the most prolific receiving tight end ever, but he was also among the career receiving leaders period: #2 in receptions behind Jerry Rice, #6 in receiving yards behind Rice, Larry Fitzgerald, Terrell Owens, Randy Moss, and Isaac Bruce, and #8 in receiving touchdowns. Likewise, Gonzalez holds a distinct edge over Gronkowski in Pro Bowls (14 vs. 5) and All-Pro selections (6 vs. 4); the 14 career Pro Bowls are also tied for most all-time as of the end of the 2018 season with Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Bruce Matthews, and Merlin Olsen. However, in terms of per-game greatness and standout seasons, the numbers are much closer: over 270 career regular season games, Gonzalez averaged 4.91 receptions for 56.03 yards and 0.41 touchdowns per game vs. 4.34 receptions for 64.94 yards and 0.64 touchdowns per game over 143 career games for Gronkowski. Similarly, Gonzalez has a similar number of 1,000-yard and double-digit touchdown seasons (4x and 3x, respectively) as Gronkowski (4x and 5x, respectively). Unsurprisingly, Gonzalez was inducted into Canton in 2019, and Gronkowski will surely get the call when his time comes as well.
Regular Season Statistics
| Tony Gonzalez | Player | Rob Gronkowski |
| 17 (1997-2013) | Seasons | 9 (2010-2018) |
| 270 | Games Played | 115 |
| 1,325 | Receptions | 521 |
| 15,127 | Receiving Yards | 7,861 |
| 111 | Receiving Touchdowns | 79 |
| 14x | Pro Bowls | 5x |
| 6x | All-Pro | 4x |
| – | Super Bowls | 3x |
| – | Other Awards | Comeback Player |
| 2019 | Hall of Fame Induction | – |
Source: Pro-Football-Reference.com
In an interesting twist, while Gonzalez had a much longer overall career, it was Gronkowski who had the much longer postseason resume, which culminated in four Super Bowl appearances and two championships.
Over his long career, Gonzalez made six trips to the playoffs, but only advanced past his team’s first game (whether it be the Wildcard or Divisional round) once. As a Falcon, his second-to-last NFL season was his best postseason performance, as top-seeded Atlanta made it to the NFC Championship Game where they lost to the San Francisco 49ers; over two games played, Gonzalez racked up 14 catches for 129 yards and a pair of touchdowns. Interestingly, in seven postseason games, he never had a 100-yard or multi-touchdown game, with his final playoff game being his best (8 receptions for 78 yards and a touchdown).
In contrast, Gronkowski appeared in the postseason in every one of his healthy seasons (so excluding 2013 and 2016), playing in five Super Bowls and winning four of them. During the 2011 playoff run that ended in a 21-17 upset loss to the New York Giants in Super Bowl XLVI, Gronkowski had his best individual postseason with 17 catches for 258 yards and 3 touchdowns, though was limited in the Super Bowl by injury. Three years later, in 2014, he won his first championship, contributing 6 catches for 68 yards and a touchdown in a Super Bowl XLIX victory over the Seattle Seahawks. Gronkowski also had a great individual performance (116 yards and 2 touchdowns) in Super Bowl LII in 2017, but once again the mighty Patriots were upset, this time 41-33 to the Philadelphia Eagles. In his last NFL game as a Patriot, he put up 87 yards in a grind-it-out 13-3 win vs. the Los Angeles Rams in Super Bowl LIII. Finally, in his first season with the Buccaneers, Gronkowski had 6 catches for 67 yards and a pair of touchdowns in a 31-9 triumph over the Kansas City Chiefs in Super Bowl LV. Overall, at the time of his second retirement, Gronkowski held a number of postseason and Super Bowl records, including most career postseason receiving yards by a tight end (1,389), most postseason touchdowns by a tight end (15), and most receptions and yards by a tight end in Super Bowls (29 catches for 364 yards).
Playoff Statistics
| Tony Gonzalez | Player | Rob Gronkowski |
| 7 | Games Played | 22 |
| 30 | Receptions | 98 |
| 286 | Receiving Yards | 1,389 |
| 4 | Receiving Touchdowns | 15 |
Source: Pro-Football-Reference.com
Every athlete goes through a natural career lifecycle, from starting off as a rookie to reaching peak years of performance and finally, declining into the inevitable retirement due to a combination of age and/or injury; though Gonzalez was incredibly consistent throughout his career, Gronkowski’s greatness was in part diminished by his inability to remain healthy. For Hall of Fame caliber players across sports, I like to look at a concept I call a “decade of dominance.” The thinking behind this is that for most Hall of Fame type careers, there are roughly 10 great seasons that define an athlete (this idea is embodied in a sense by the NFL’s All-Decade teams, of which Gonzalez and Gronkowski are on for the 2000s and 2010s, respectively), though due to injury or other factors, they might not be 10 consecutive years. However, given Gronkowski’s shorter NFL career (11 total seasons, with nine relatively full and healthy ones), I have modified it in this comparison to a “(half)-decade of dominance”.
(Half)-Decade of Dominance
| Tony Gonzalez | Player | Rob Gronkowski |
| 2000, 2003-2004, 2007-2008 | (Half)-Decade of Dominance | 2011-2012, 2014-2015, 2017 |
| 80 | Games Played | 71 |
| 461 | Receptions | 368 |
| 5,607 | Receiving Yards | 5,501 |
| 41 | Receiving Touchdowns | 59 |
Source: Pro-Football-Reference.com
This is perhaps a better apples-to-apples comparison of Gonzalez vs. Gronkowski; across their five best years, Gonzalez still played more games and accumulated far more receptions and slightly more yardage, but Gronkowski was the much more prolific touchdown threat.
My Thoughts
As already alluded to, the career comparison between Tony Gonzalez and Rob Gronkowski is a contrast between a player who was incredibly good over a very long period of time vs. a player who was arguably the best ever when healthy, but had trouble staying on the field. The contrasts do not end there – Gonzalez played with many quarterbacks over the course of his career and never came close to winning the Super Bowl, while Gronkowski had the luxury of catching passes from Tom Brady and was a fixture in the playoffs and Super Bowl, establishing himself as the most prolific postseason tight end ever. Ultimately, the debates boil down to if you value sustained and consistent greatness or a player’s absolute peak, no matter how long or how short that may be. For me, I believe that a key part of what makes a player an all-time great is that player’s ability to maintain the greatness for a prolonged period of time and as a result, my preference is for Gonzalez in the best tight end ever debate (though Gronkowski is nevertheless top-five all-time at the position as well).
Thus, after weighing their careers against each other in terms of statistics, achievements, and impact, the winner of this faceoff is:
Tony Gonzalez
As always, vote for your choice and leave your thoughts and comments below.
Further Reading
More Good Stuff
- Watch: Get tickets to see the Kansas City Chiefs, New England Patriots, or any other NFL team in action
- Wear: Buy sports apparel for the Chiefs, Patriots, or any other NFL team
- Collect: Buy unique sports memorabilia for Tony Gonzalez, Rob Gronkowski, or your favorite NFL player(s) or team(s)
- Play: Show off your football knowledge by playing daily fantasy football
- Build: Start your own sports website/blog
Previous
H2H 35: Paul Kariya vs. Martin St. Louis
2 responses to “H2H 36: Tony Gonzalez vs. Rob Gronkowski – Who was Better?”