Tag Archives: best running quarterbacks

H2H 96: Donovan McNabb vs. Steve McNair – Who was Better?

While the modern NFL game features a growing number of dual-threat quarterbacks (think Patrick Maholmes, Lamar Jackson, Russell Wilson, Deshaun Watson, Cam Newton, Josh Allen, Kyler Murray, etc.), signal callers who can make plays with both their arm and their legs were not always in such high demand.  Nevertheless, during the late 1990s and early 2000s, the league began to see an influx of multi-talented quarterbacks such as Kordell Stewart, Michael Vick, Donovan McNabb, and Steve McNair, just to name a few.  In particular, McNabb and McNair, though never quite as flashy as some of their peers (e.g. Vick) each became consistent Pro Bowl quarterbacks capable of leading their respective teams to the Super Bowl.  With similar and overlapping NFL careers, let us look back upon these pioneer dual-threat quarterbacks and ask the question:

Who was better – Donovan McNabb or Steve McNair?

Continue reading

H2H 14: Randall Cunningham vs. Michael Vick – Who was Better?

For most of the modern NFL era, general managers and coaches have had a very defined view of the prototypical quarterback: a tall, usually white, relatively immobile player who is a traditional pocket passer with a strong arm.  Even as black quarterbacks such as James Harris, Doug Williams, and Warren Moon began to enter the league, they were still relatively traditional quarterbacks; however, the NFL would soon witness the advent of the dual-threat quarterback with “The Ultimate Weapon” Randall Cunningham in the late 1980s and then later, the electric Michael Vick in early 2000s.  As mobile, scrambling quarterbacks have become more popular at all levels of football, we look back upon two of the pioneers of the dual-threat quarterback and ask:

Who was better – Randall Cunningham or Michael Vick?

Continue reading