Tag Archives: decade of dominance

H2H 143: Bartolo Colon vs. Dennis Martinez – Who was Better?

With his 246th career win in August 2018, Bartolo Colon surpassed Dennis Martinez for most wins in MLB history by a Latin American-born pitcher; two decades earlier in 1998, Martinez himself had broken the previous record held by Juan Marichal.  While Marichal was a surefire Hall of Fame pitcher, both Colon and Martinez were longtime workhorses and at times, staff aces, who pitched more than 20+ years apiece and were consistently good, sometimes great.  As two of the best Latin American pitchers ever with similar overall careers spanning well into their 40s, it makes for a natural comparison:

Who was better – Bartolo Colon or Dennis Martinez?

Continue reading

H2H 142: Chauncey Billups vs. Kevin Johnson – Who was Better?

Point guards act as the “floor generals” for a basketball team and often set the tone as the heart and soul of a team, thus serving as an imperative piece of a winning franchise.  For the Phoenix Suns in the 1990s and the Detroit Pistons in the 2000s, the two teams played very different styles of basketball (a fast-paced frenetic offensive style for the former, a more defense-minded, grind-it-out mentality for the latter), but were linked by the common factor of having an elite point guard in Kevin Johnson and Chauncey Billups, respectively.  Though neither was ever regarded as THE best point guard in the NBA, both were top-tier floor generals for roughly a decade for among the winningest teams of their eras, thus bringing up the comparison:

Who was better – Chauncey Billups or Kevin Johnson?

Continue reading

H2H 141: Shane Doan vs. Ryan Smyth – Who was Better?

Every sports team’s fan base has its share of franchise favorites – though these may not necessarily be the best players in the team’s history (they can be), they have usually been around with the team through thick and thin and are both leaders and class acts.  For the Arizona Coyotes and the Edmonton Oilers in the NHL, perhaps the most popular players in (recent) franchise history are Shane Doan and Ryan Smyth, respectively – outstanding hockey players in their own right, they each led their respective teams through rather bleak periods with class and dignity, thus forever earning a place in the hearts of the fans; given their relatively parallel careers, it is only natural to compare the pair and ask:

Who was better – Shane Doan or Ryan Smyth?

Continue reading

H2H 140: James Harrison vs. Joey Porter – Who was Better?

Beginning with the days of the “Steel Curtain” in the 1970s, the Pittsburgh Steelers have always been characterized by a ferocious defense; in particular, from the likes of Greg Lloyd and Kevin Greene to Jason Gildon to T.J. Watt today, a hallmark of their defensive scheme has consistently been elite pass-rushing outside linebackers.  Notably, in the 2000s, the Steelers defense was anchored by successive brash pass-rushers, first with Joey Porter and then followed by James Harrison.  Both among the top five career sack leaders in team history, each was an intimidating (and perhaps at times, dirty) player who will go down in team lore as a legend, but the question is:

Who was better – James Harrison or Joey Porter?

Continue reading

H2H 139: Roy Oswalt vs. Jake Peavy – Who was Better?

The NL saw a plethora of elite starting pitchers during the 2000s – in addition to the overpowering dominance of Randy Johnson and Curt Schilling in the early 2000s to Tim Lincecum’s back-to-back Cy Youngs at the end of the decade, other star pitchers included the likes of Roy Halladay, Brandon Webb, Chris Carpenter, Johan Santana, etc.  Notably, two young aces that came up at the beginning of the decade were Roy Oswalt and Jake Peavy – with nearly parallel careers, the duo were consistently among the top pitchers in the league year in and year out throughout the decade, thus bringing about an interesting comparison:

Who was better – Roy Oswalt or Jake Peavy?

Continue reading

H2H 138: Steven Jackson vs. Marshawn Lynch – Who was Better?

The prototype power running back is an all-around offensive weapon who can carry a team’s offense with his ability to pound the football while also having the ability to catch passes out of the backfield.  Over the past 20 years, two of the best power running backs to come around in the NFL have been Steven Jackson and Marshawn Lynch – in their respective primes, each was a true workhorse back known for his punishing running style and consistently producing 1,000-yard seasons year in and year out.  With both players having hung up their cleats in recent years, it is perhaps a natural comparison to ask:

Who was better – Steven Jackson or Marshawn Lynch?

Continue reading

H2H 137: Doug Gilmour vs. Joe Nieuwendyk – Who was Better?

The 2011 Hockey Hall of Fame class featured four highly-decorated NHL players: goalie Ed Belfour, defenseman Mark Howe, and centers Doug Gilmour and Joe Nieuwendyk.  Among the illustrious foursome, perhaps it is only fitting that Gilmour and Nieuwendyk were inducted together – each was an elite center in the late 1980s and throughout the 1990s, scored over 1,000 career points, served as a team captain, and the duo even played on the same team and won a Stanley Cup together.  Given the similarities, let us look at these parallel Hall of Fame careers and examine the question:

Who was better – Doug Gilmour or Joe Nieuwendyk?

Continue reading

H2H 136: Michael Finley vs. Joe Johnson – Who was Better?

Swingmen/wings (i.e. basketball players that can play either shooting guard or small forward) are typically among the most versatile basketball players on the court; moreover, one of the best abilities is availability, so add in durability to a diverse skill set and you have a very valuable player.  Two NBA stars who fit this description nearly to a “T” were Michael Finley and Joe Johnson – at their respective peaks, both were iron men on the court who played roughly 40 minutes a night and scored 20+ points per game with solid rebounding and assists totals as well.  Given their similar abilities and career trajectories, it is only natural to compare the pair and ask:

Who was better – Michael Finley or Joe Johnson?

Continue reading

H2H 135: Rollie Fingers vs. Goose Gossage – Who was Better?

The modern-day closer is a highly-specialized role, with most top-tier closers rarely pitching more than one inning at a time to lock down the victory.  However, if you go back half a century or so to the nascent days of the closer (or firemen, as they were known back then) circa the 1970s, end-of-game relief pitchers at that time would commonly pitch one, two, or even three innings at a time to nail down the victory.  In those early “Wild West” days of relief pitching, two pioneering pitchers who would pave the way for today’s closers were Rollie Fingers and Rich “Goose” Gossage – as the first two players in MLB history to reach 300 career saves (while saving winning and losing 100+ games apiece), they were at the vanguard of baseball’s evolution; thus, between these two contemporaries, it is only natural to ask the question:

Who was better – Rollie Fingers or Goose Gossage?

Continue reading

H2H 134: Jay Cutler vs. Tony Romo – Who was Better?

Perhaps no position in professional sports is as heavily scrutinized as the quarterback in football – win and you get all the glory, but lose and the burden of blame falls squarely on your shoulders.  During the 21st century, perhaps no two quarterbacks have been as heavily criticized during their playing days as Jay Cutler and Tony Romo – though each put up prolific passing numbers in his prime, neither could guide their teams to much postseason success and thus were constantly under the microscope for perceived shortcomings.  With both quarterbacks having retired from the NFL as players and made their way into the broadcasting booth, let us look back on the parallel careers of these much-maligned signal-callers and consider:

Who was better – Jay Cutler or Tony Romo?

Continue reading