Tag Archives: decade of dominance

H2H 103: Marian Hossa vs. Alexander Mogilny – Who was Better?

As part of the 2020 Hockey Hall of Fame class, Marian Hossa was selected in his first year of eligibility; while Hossa was certainly worthy of induction, Alexander Mogilny, who has been on the ballot for more than a decade, was snubbed once again.  Yet a closer look at the statistics and accomplishments of Hossa and Mogilny show two players who were relatively evenly matched in terms of both peak performance and overall career achievements – thus, let us compare these two offensively gifted Eastern European NHL stars and evaluate the question:

Who was better – Marian Hossa or Alexander Mogilny?

Continue reading

H2H 102: Juan Marichal vs. Jim Palmer – Who was Better?

When you think of the great pitchers of the 1960s and 1970s, the first names that probably come to mind are the likes of Sandy Koufax in the early to mid-1960s, Bob Gibson in the mid to late-1960s, Tom Seaver in the 1970s, etc.  And while those pitchers were certainly legends of the game, two other consistently dominant hurlers from that era who may not have gotten the same fanfare were Juan Marichal and Jim Palmer (in fact, Marichal may be one of the most underrated pitchers in MLB history).  Despite the stark contrasts between the two – Dominican-born vs. All-American, NL vs. AL, West Coast vs. East Coast, etc., there are also numerous similarities in their consistent brilliance over a decade plus each.  Thus, let us compare Marichal and Palmer side-by-side and ask the question:

Who was better – Juan Marichal or Jim Palmer?

Continue reading

H2H 101: Patrick Ewing vs. Alonzo Mourning – Who was Better?

After John Thompson Jr. took over as the head coach of the Georgetown men’s basketball team in 1972, he helped turn the program into a powerhouse, in the process producing numerous future NBA stars.  While the Hoyas have certainly sent a number of elite guards to the NBA (e.g. Allen Iverson and Sleepy Flood), they are perhaps best known for their outstanding big men.  In particular, two giants (literally) who stood out at both the college and later professional level were centers Patrick Ewing and Alonzo Mourning; both were All-Americans at Georgetown, top NBA draft picks, and yearly All-Star/All-NBA performers – given their close Georgetown ties and later rivalry in the NBA, it is an inevitable comparison and question:

Who was better – Patrick Ewing or Alonzo Mourning?

Continue reading

H2H 100: Chad Johnson vs. Keyshawn Johnson – Who was Better?

In the NFL, the wide receiver position is probably most associated with primadonna or diva-type players, i.e. talented pass-catchers who also like to trash talk, run their mouths, and generally make news off the field – think Randy Moss, Terrell Owens, Michael Irvin, Antonio Brown, etc.  During the past two decades or so of professional football, two of the brashest and best wide receivers who fit this mold were Chad Johnson and Keyshawn Johnson, who are actually related (Chad is Keyshawn’s cousin).  At their relative peaks, each wide receiver was not only an annual 1,000-yard threat, but also generated weekly headlines unrelated to their in-game performances.  While passing numbers have become increasingly inflated over time, both still have impressive career totals of 750+ receptions, 10,000+ receiving yards, and 60+ receiving touchdowns – given their similar career numbers, personalities, and familial relationship, it seems only natural to ask the question:

Who was better – Chad Johnson or Keyshawn Johnson?

Continue reading

H2H 99: Jarome Iginla vs. Brendan Shanahan – Who was Better?

With his selection to the Hockey Hall of Fame in 2020, Jarome Iginla represents perhaps the last of a dying breed of hockey player: the quintessential power forward (think Gordie Howe, Mark Messier, Cam Neely, Phil Esposito, or Eric Lindros).  In fact, with both his physical style of play plus his knack for putting points on the board (career totals of 600+ goals and 1,300+ points), Iginla’s game in many ways resembles that of another great power forward from an earlier generation in Brendan Shanahan.  Both were not only consistent point-per-game producers for two decades each, but were also not afraid to drop their gloves if necessary – see this fight between the pair from 2001.  Thus, with Iginla rightfully joining Shanahan in the Hall of Fame, let us compare these two skilled physical forces and ask:

Who was better – Jarome Iginla or Brendan Shanahan?

Continue reading

H2H 98: Dave Parker vs. Jim Rice – Who was Better?

In 1978, the winners of baseball’s annual MVP awards were Dave Parker and Jim Rice in the NL and AL, respectively, as each slugger hit above .300 with 30+ home runs, 100+ runs batted in, and 100+ runs scored.  Overall, these two power-hitting outfielders were among the elite ballplayers of their era and each one retired with a .290+ career batting average, 2,400+ hits, 300+ home runs, 1,400+ runs batted in, and 1,200+ runs scored.  However, while Rice was finally inducted to the Baseball Hall of Fame on his 15th and final try, Parker never came close to reaching the 75% threshold during his time on the ballot; for supporters of Parker’s candidacy, they often point to the career of Rice as a benchmark given the close parallels between their careers – as such, let us compare these two feared sluggers of the 1970s and 1980s and ask:

Who was better – Dave Parker or Jim Rice?

Continue reading

H2H 97: Baron Davis vs. Deron Williams – Who was Better?

Traditionally, point guards are the smallest players on the basketball court – short and relatively slight of build, yet fearless as floor generals, e.g. Isiah Thomas, John Stockton, Steve Nash, or Chris Paul.  In recent times, though, the game has seen more and more “big” point guards dominating and controlling the court (think Magic Johnson, Jason Kidd, or more recently, Ben Simmons and Russell Westbrook); during the 2000s, two ballhandlers who fit this new mold of the physically dominant point guard were Baron Davis and Deron Williams – each measuring in at 6’3” and weighing 200+ pounds, the duo were among the league’s elite point guards in their prime with the ability to both score against smaller defenders and dish it out with the best of them.  With each player having seen his brilliance come and gone, let us look back on their notable careers and ponder the question:

Who was better – Baron Davis or Deron Williams?

Continue reading

H2H 96: Donovan McNabb vs. Steve McNair – Who was Better?

While the modern NFL game features a growing number of dual-threat quarterbacks (think Patrick Maholmes, Lamar Jackson, Russell Wilson, Deshaun Watson, Cam Newton, Josh Allen, Kyler Murray, etc.), signal callers who can make plays with both their arm and their legs were not always in such high demand.  Nevertheless, during the late 1990s and early 2000s, the league began to see an influx of multi-talented quarterbacks such as Kordell Stewart, Michael Vick, Donovan McNabb, and Steve McNair, just to name a few.  In particular, McNabb and McNair, though never quite as flashy as some of their peers (e.g. Vick) each became consistent Pro Bowl quarterbacks capable of leading their respective teams to the Super Bowl.  With similar and overlapping NFL careers, let us look back upon these pioneer dual-threat quarterbacks and ask the question:

Who was better – Donovan McNabb or Steve McNair?

Continue reading

H2H 95: Bob Gibson vs. Tom Seaver – Who was Better?

1969 was a seminal season in MLB history – not only did the league lower the pitching mound from 15 to 10 inches after “The Year of the Pitcher” in 1968, but it was also the first season with divisions and an expanded postseason, thus culminating in an improbable World Series title for the New York Mets AKA “The Amazin’ Mets”.  Two of the key baseball figures at the center of these monumental events were pitchers Bob Gibson of the St. Louis Cardinals and Tom Seaver of the Mets – the former had arguably the most dominant pitching season ever in 1968, while the latter led the “Miracle Mets” to their unexpected first championship.  Both multiple Cy Young winners and eventual Hall of Famers, the duo were among the elite pitchers of the era and faced off against each other on numerous occasions in the NL, thus leading to the natural comparison:

Who was better – Bob Gibson or Tom Seaver?

Continue reading

H2H 94: Jeremy Roenick vs. Keith Tkachuk – Who was Better?

One of hockey’s magical milestones is the 500-goal club and as of the end of the 2019-2020 season, there were a total of five American players in that elite company: Brett Hull (dual Canadian/American citizenship), Joe Mullen, Mike Modano, Jeremy Roenick, and Keith Tkachuk.  While the first three members of this fraternity are Hall of Famers, Roenick and Tkachuk remain on the outside looking in despite 500+ career goals and 1,000+ career points apiece in the NHL.  During their long and productive NHL careers, both were not only among the best offensive players of the 1990s, but were also known for their tough, hard-nosed (dirty?) play; as teammates on the Phoenix Coyotes as well as on Team USA, in comparing these all-time American greats, let us ask the question:

Who was better – Jeremy Roenick or Keith Tkachuk?

Continue reading