Tag Archives: sports H2H

H2H 15: Chris Evert vs. Martina Navratilova – Who was Better?

Throughout the history of tennis, different eras have been defined by their hallmark rivalries, whether it be Roger Federer vs. Rafael Nadal currently, Pete Sampras vs. Andre Agassi in the 1990s, or Jimmy Connors vs. John McEnroe in the 1970s and 1980s.  Oftentimes, these great rivalries are characterized by their great contrasts; this was certainly the case with arguably the greatest women’s rivalry in tennis history between Chris Evert and Martina Navratilova. Over the course of nearly twenty years, the All-American baseliner and the Czech-born serve and volley-er dominated the women’s game and each staked their claim to best women’s player ever (though Serena Williams has likely surpassed both in recent years) – even today, the debate rages on:

Who was better – Chris Evert or Martina Navratilova?

Continue reading

H2H 14: Randall Cunningham vs. Michael Vick – Who was Better?

For most of the modern NFL era, general managers and coaches have had a very defined view of the prototypical quarterback: a tall, usually white, relatively immobile player who is a traditional pocket passer with a strong arm.  Even as black quarterbacks such as James Harris, Doug Williams, and Warren Moon began to enter the league, they were still relatively traditional quarterbacks; however, the NFL would soon witness the advent of the dual-threat quarterback with “The Ultimate Weapon” Randall Cunningham in the late 1980s and then later, the electric Michael Vick in early 2000s.  As mobile, scrambling quarterbacks have become more popular at all levels of football, we look back upon two of the pioneers of the dual-threat quarterback and ask:

Who was better – Randall Cunningham or Michael Vick?

Continue reading

H2H 13: Daniel Sedin vs. Henrik Sedin – Who was Better?

Much like father and son duos (see Bobby and Brett Hull), there have been many great sibling combos in sports history, from Peyton and Eli Manning in football to Pau and Marc Gasol in basketball to the Alou and DiMaggio brothers in baseball to Phil and Tony Esposito in hockey, etc. Go a step further and there have even been numerous accomplished sets of identical twins (Ronde and Tiki Barber, Brook and Robin Lopez, etc.) – however with the exception of doubles partners Bob and Mike Bryan in tennis, perhaps no brothers/identical twins have had their careers quite as intertwined as Daniel and Henrik Sedin.  As long-time stalwarts for the Vancouver Canucks, the brothers were drafted together, played their entire careers with the Canucks together, and retired together. Given how closely their careers were linked (you could almost say they were identical…), naturally one might ask:

Who was better – Daniel Sedin or Henrik Sedin?

Continue reading

H2H 12: Hakeem Olajuwon vs. David Robinson – Who was Better?

While today’s NBA game values finesse and shooting (particularly from the three-point line), the 1980s and 1990s saw a different style of play that focused on power and physicality.  As such, the old-school NBA was dominated by towering seven-foot centers that controlled the paint both offensively and defensively, and often formed the foundation of successful teams during that time.  In an era that featured centers like Shaquille O’Neal, Patrick Ewing, Alonzo Mourning, Brad Daugherty, and Dikembe Mutombo, just to name a few, two of most dominant big men were Hakeem “The Dream” Olajuwon of the Houston Rockets and David “The Admiral” Robinson of the San Antonio Spurs.  Each player was a number one overall pick, an MVP, a Defensive Player of the Year, and an NBA champion, leading to inevitable comparisons and the obvious question:

Who was better – Hakeem Olajuwon or David Robinson?

Continue reading

H2H 11: Johnny Bench vs. Yogi Berra – Who was Better?

Catcher might be one of the most difficult positions to play in all of sports, and certainly in baseball, as it is both physically taxing (squatting behind the plate for three hours while wearing heavy equipment) and mentally demanding (calling the pitches, managing runners on base, etc.).  Given the heavy responsibilities bestowed upon the catcher, the focus for most baseball teams is to have a great defensive backstop, with any offense being icing on the cake; as such, this makes a catcher who is both offensively and defensively gifted a bit of a unicorn and thus, extremely valuable.  Throughout the history of baseball, there have only been a select group of catchers who have excelled in both facets of the game, and unsurprisingly, most of them are Hall of Famers. When it comes to the discussion around the greatest catcher ever, chief among the handful of contenders includes Johnny Bench, one of the engines of Cincinnati’s “Big Red Machine” in the 1970s, and Lawrence “Yogi” Berra, who backstopped the New York Yankees dynasty of the 1950s and 1960s and is remembered as much for his quirky Berra-isms as he was for his play.  In comparing the careers and achievements of the towering Bench and the diminutive Berra, the question is:

Who was better – Johnny Bench or Yogi Berra?

Continue reading

H2H 10: Bobby Hull vs. Brett Hull – Who was Better?

Across the world of professional sports, there have been many great father-son athletes throughout history, from Bobby and Barry Bonds in baseball to Dell and Steph Curry in basketball to the Mannings in football (father Archie and sons Peyton and Eli), etc.  However, in terms of the greatest father-son duo ever, those honors might go to hockey players Bobby and Brett Hull. Known respectively as “The Golden Jet” and “The Golden Brett”, both father and son led the NHL in goal scoring, were named MVP, and reached the magical 500 career goal mark, among other honors, and are the first father and son combo to both be inducted as Hall of Famers in their sport.  Each player is an all-time hockey great in their own right, but in comparing father and son side-by-side, we ask the question:

Who was better – Bobby Hull or Brett Hull?

Continue reading

H2H 9: Dan Fouts vs. Warren Moon – Who was Better?

With the evolution of offense in today’s quarterback-friendly and pass-happy NFL, a quarterback passing for 4,000+ yards and 30+ touchdowns is an increasingly common occurrence, and throwing for 3,000+ yards and 20+ touchdowns is almost the bare minimum for a starting signal-caller.  However, if you turn the clock back a few decades to when the quarterback was less of a protected species and defensive players were allowed more freedom in how they operated, big passing numbers were more of the exception than the norm. During that era of professional football, two quarterbacks who were ahead of their time in putting up gaudy passing stats were Dan Fouts in the San Diego Chargers’ “Air Coryell” offense and Warren Moon operating the Houston Oilers’ “Run and shoot” attack.  As pioneers and trailblazers in paving the way towards today’s style of pro football, both would make their way to the Pro Football Hall of Fame and leave an indelible mark on the game, which begs the question:

Who was better – Dan Fouts or Warren Moon?

Continue reading

H2H 8: Walter Johnson vs. Christy Mathewson – Who was Better?

Every year, the Hall of Fame voting process for enshrinement into Cooperstown ignites a storm of debate over who should make it, who should not, whether this player is more deserving than that one, etc.  This annual tradition began on February 2, 1936, when five men were elected to baseball’s inaugural Hall of Fame class. Taking into consideration only “modern” players (i.e. careers started after 1900), this illustrious quintet included the then (and for many years thereafter) home run king Babe Ruth, the all-time hits leader Ty Cobb, the legendary shortstop Honus Wagner, and two of the preeminent pitchers of the day, Walter Johnson and Christy Mathewson.  As arguably two of the greatest pitchers of the early 20th century whose careers will forever be linked by their status as one of the first five baseball immortals, the question naturally arises:

Who was better – Walter Johnson or Christy Mathewson?

Continue reading

H2H 7: Ray Allen vs. Reggie Miller – Who was Better?

In today’s modern NBA game, especially with the use of analytics, the three-pointer is becoming increasingly popular.  At the forefront of this new era of sharpshooters is point guard Steph Curry of the Golden State Warriors; having already set a number of single-season three-point shooting records, Curry has moved quickly up the list of career three-point shooting and is likely to be regarded as the greatest shooter (not player, or even scorer – there is an important distinction there) in NBA history when all is said and done.  However, prior to Curry’s emergence, the two men most commonly associated with the unofficial title of best shooter in NBA history were Hall of Fame shooting guards Ray Allen and Reggie Miller. As the current record-holder and second place, respectively, for career three-pointers made and with the focus on the three-ball today, the question is:

Who was better – Ray Allen or Reggie Miller?

Continue reading

H2H 6: Marshall Faulk vs. LaDainian Tomlinson – Who was Better?

Running backs come in all shapes and sizes – big bruisers, shifty speedsters, goal-line specialists, third-down pass-catching backs, etc.  In an era of increasing specialization and running backs by committee, the most coveted backs are still the ones that can play all three downs and represent both a rushing and receiving threat.  Any list of the most dangerous all-purpose backs in NFL history who were equally good at running between the tackles and catching a screen pass in the flat would include Marshall Faulk and LaDainian Tomlinson.  As football fans and fantasy players of the last 20 years will remember, in their prime, Faulk and Tomlinson were elite offensive weapons who racked up yards, catches, and perhaps most importantly, touchdowns at an extraordinary rate, on their way to Hall of Fame careers.  With both players having hung up their cleats and been immortalized in Canton, the question is:

Who was better – Marshall Faulk or LaDainian Tomlinson?

Continue reading